Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

Home Search
What Happens When You Overprice Your Home

What Happens When You Overprice Your Home

The first mistake most sellers make? Thinking they need to “leave room to negotiate.”

 

It sounds smart on the surface—price a little high, see what happens, and come down if you need to.

 

But in today’s market, that move can cost you real money.

 

 

Today’s Buyers Are Smarter Than Ever

 

 

Thanks to apps like Zillow, Redfin, and Realtor.com, buyers can analyze your home—and its price—before they ever contact their agent. They’ve already seen recent comps. They’ve already calculated price-per-square-foot. They might even know what your neighbor’s house sold for.

 

So when a home is clearly overpriced, they don’t assume you’re open to offers—they assume you’re unrealistic. And they move on.

 

 

You Only Get One Shot at That First Wave of Attention

 

 

Every listing gets the most attention in its first 7–10 days. That’s when serious buyers and their agents are watching for new inventory. If you’re priced right, that early momentum can lead to:

 

  • Multiple showings
  • Strong offers
  • Better terms
  • Less time on the market

 

 

If you’re overpriced? You miss that wave. And once that moment passes, it’s hard to get it back.

 

 

The Real Risk Isn’t Just Time—It’s Perception

 

 

When a home sits too long, buyers start wondering what’s wrong with it—even if nothing is. Price reductions only reinforce that doubt.

 

You might eventually sell, but often:

 

  • You get fewer offers
  • You negotiate from a weaker position
  • You sell for less than if you had priced it right to begin with

 

 

 

What Smart Pricing Looks Like

 

 

Smart pricing isn’t about going low—it’s about hitting the market with clarity and confidence. That’s how you create urgency. That’s how you attract strong, motivated buyers.

 

As an agent, I don’t just pull a number from a spreadsheet. I analyze:

 

  • Recent comparable sales
  • Active competition
  • Local demand
  • How your property shows online
  • Where buyers are coming from—and what they’re expecting

 

 

From there, we build a strategy that works.

 

 

The Bottom Line

 

 

Overpricing might sound harmless. But in today’s digital, data-driven market, it can be the reason serious buyers never even step through the door.

 

If you’re thinking about selling, don’t guess. Let’s talk through what your home is really worth—and how to position it for maximum attention and the best possible outcome.

 

Reach out for a free, honest market evaluation.

 

 [email protected]

 989-350-4856

Work With Casey

Working with Casey Gilling means more than just buying or selling a home—it means experiencing a higher level of service. Casey’s personalized approach ensures every detail is handled with care and expertise, making your journey seamless and stress-free.

Follow Me on Instagram